For the first part of our seminar paper last spring, Dr. Bluemel had students create an introduction for a fictional critical edition of the text of our choice. I chose Italo Calvino’s If On A Winter’s Night A Traveler. Overall, I like what I did with this part of the assignment. Some of my disagreements with the theorists I chose are not adequately explored, but for the most part I like what I did. There is one article I wish I did not pick, which was a big mistake on my part: I should have taken the time to find a more suitable article. Some of my prose was very awkward and should have gone through more revision before the final version was finished. I have cleaned it up since then. In the future I need to have peers review my work during the revision process because there are things I seem to always miss.
The second, much more enjoyable, part of our seminar paper was reviewing a critical edition of a text. I decided to use Sherlock Holmes: The Major Stories With Contemporary Critical Essays that Bedford published. I really enjoyed writing this part of the paper. The issues involved with the creation of a critical edition of a text and what to include in it are fascinating and something I want to engage with further in the future. (PDF)